Former Judge Tracie Hunter Released From Jail, Vows to Fight On

Former Hamilton County Juvenile Court Judge, Tracie Hunter, who earned her undergraduate degree from Miami University in 1988 and her Juris Doctorate from the University of Cincinnati College of Law in 1992, is released after serving three months of a six-month sentence

By Stacy M. Brown, NNPA Newswire Correspondent

Tracie Hunter, the first African American juvenile court judge in Hamilton County history, is free again after serving nearly three months of a six-month jail sentence following her conviction on charges of unlawful interest in a public contract. She was found guilty of helping her brother keep his county job by mishandling a confidential document.

In July, Hunter was dragged off to prison after going limp in the courtroom while demonstrators protested her incarceration.

As news broadcasts showed a sheriff’s deputy dragging the former judge away, Hunter told NNPA Newswire that she mostly blacked out.

“As I previously shared with [The Black Press], I had very extensive injuries from an accident. I had a metal rod in my back, and it limits my mobility,” Hunter explained.

“Then, after the judge imposed the sentence, there was so much commotion, and I and my attorney both were hit in the back of our heads. At that point, everything became a blur. The next thing I knew, I was being dragged across the courtroom floor,” Hunter stated.

Once behind bars, things only got worse.

Hunter said her health began to decline, guards mistreated her regularly, and regular showers were denied.

Guards also searched her small cell often, and without cause, Hunter stated.

“I was treated horribly by the guards. They talked to me in cruel and disrespectful ways,” she noted. “They searched my cell all of the time, and often I’d be the only person they’d search. On one occasion, they went to the room next to me and told the people there to pretend they were searching that room, but they were searching my room.”

During one of the searches, Hunter alleges that prison guards entered her cell and “absolutely tore it apart.”

“One time, they said they were searching for drugs, and what’s odd is that they know I have never done drugs, and I don’t drink. But there were others in there because of drugs, and they didn’t search them for drugs,” Hunter stated.

The only thing guards ever confiscated from Hunter were writing pens, which she believed was within her rights to possess.

Worse, Hunter stated that she would routinely be on lockdown, once for as long as 25 consecutive hours. Rarely did she eat because she feared guards might have poisoned her food.

“They’d bring me my food, but I wasn’t going to eat it because they had treated me so viciously. They were handling my food, so I thought it might have been poisoned,” Hunter stated.

Jail nurses would provide Hunter apples and Gatorade to help keep her from starvation and dehydration, she said.

“Mistreatment was going on daily. Most of the time, I was freezing cold, and I wore like five shirts every day, around the clock,” Hunter noted.

Hunter, who earned her undergraduate degree from Miami University in 1988 and her Juris Doctorate from the University of Cincinnati College of Law in 1992, won the election in 2010.

She stunned the Republican-heavy city by defeating GOP contender John Williams.

Williams and the GOP contested Hunter’s victory, and a heated court battle ensued.

After numerous appeals by the Hamilton County Board of Elections, officials refused to count more than 800 votes from majority Democrat and Black precincts.

Hunter then filed a federal lawsuit to have those votes counted.

While the court finally ordered the count, election officials still certified Williams as the victor.

Eventually, the election was overturned in Hunter’s favor.

The 18-month period proved pivotal because of then-Gov. John Kasich appointment of Williams to the bench.

The state Supreme Court changed the rules giving Williams administrative authority over the court.

As the senior judge and the only one elected, Hunter would have received the position of the administrative judge.

Still, Hunter worked behind the bench to protect the rights of children, including refusing to allow their names and faces to appear in news coverage.

Among other things, she instilled a system that focused on rehabilitation instead of incarceration.

Hunter mandated prosecutors turn over all critical evidence to defense lawyers.

She forced the juvenile court to change its entire reporting system and outlawed the routine shackling of juveniles in her courtroom.

Hunter also received credit for exposing juvenile case statistics, which were being inaccurately reported and falsified to the Ohio Supreme Court.

She hired African Americans in key positions, reduced default judgments, and spearheaded the change of state election laws, which paved the way for ex-felons to vote.

However, the Cincinnati Enquirer and WCPO Television joined Republican county officials in the prosecutors’ and commissioners’ offices in lawsuits challenging Hunter.

“They filed 30 lawsuits in less than nine months that I was on the bench,” Hunter said.

After serving just 18 months, her enemies found a way to silence her and end her career.

Prosecutors alleged that Hunter used her judicial credit card to appeal the lawsuits filed against her by Deters, the prosecutor.

She was sentenced in July and began serving six months. The court reduced the sentence after she agreed to minister to inmates in the jail.

Hunter walked out of jail on Saturday, Oct. 5 but her legal and personal battles are far from over. “I’m continuing to fight this wrongful conviction until it’s overturned,” Hunter stated.

“I committed no crime. All of this was a vindictive, vicious, and retaliatory attack against me because I had the audacity to run for one of the most powerful positions in Hamilton County. I had the audacity to win. I had the audacity to sue the board of elections to prove that I won. They were forced by a federal court to overturn the original elections results against my opponent, who was appointed by the governor.”

Hunter continued:

“The first African American to serve on the juvenile court of Hamilton County, and you become a political prisoner who was treated horribly. Our community in Cincinnati has always been divided by race, politics, religion, and social economics. I will never apologize for something I did not do. They want me to apologize for dividing a community that was already divided. And, I’m certainly not going to apologize to a sheriff’s deputy who dragged me on the floor like a piece of trash for the entire world to see. That was demoralizing, dehumanizing, and degrading. And, on top of that, it was an African American woman whom they put up to doing that.”


  1. Teddy Tiz Pritchett on October 17, 2019 at 12:13 pm

    Wow. I just recently learned of this story. I didnt even know who the Honorable Judge Tracie Hunter (and, I still consider her honorable) was! However, after stumbling upon the court proceeding of the sentencing hearing 2019, I have since read every article, and watched every interview pertaining to Judge Hunrwr. I am praying for this sister. I applaud her for her contributions, and pray for her full vindication, and restoration of law license! It’s a travesty of justice. I hate to pull the race card. But, history has proven time and time again, had this been a white woman, these allegations would not have risen to this level. Not, by a longshot! I believe (based on what I know of the case), that she is innocent, and her fight will eventually lead to her being cleared of these charges!


    • Ray Stevens on October 23, 2019 at 7:58 pm

      She’s a liar

      • Randy Litton on January 1, 2020 at 10:39 am

        You are obviously a very stupid person to make a comment like you have. I can only hope that someday there won’t be people like you in America.

        • G Jordon on February 12, 2020 at 7:54 am

          I think you are a stupid person for h

      • Lane Love on January 9, 2020 at 10:54 am

        You must be white, ignorant and stupid

      • Fina MAGA on January 19, 2020 at 10:39 am

        A white racist person would say that.

    • Havana Hal on October 27, 2019 at 1:46 am

      She is Innocent? She’s been convicted. What did the jury get wrong?

    • Common sense on December 12, 2019 at 5:03 pm

      Another racist idiot, that immediately clarifies race over anything else

    • That’s crap. She broke the law plain and simple! on December 14, 2019 at 8:05 am

      She got caught and was clearing breaking the law. She stopped low and pulled the race card. She was gently pulled from court because she refused to walk. What a joke!

      • Lane Love on January 9, 2020 at 10:55 am

        The joke is that this type of bigotry and racism is still going on in America

      • Justice for judge hunter on January 14, 2020 at 10:17 am

        This miscarriage of justice cost the extremely honourable judge hunter 3 months of her life in horrible conditions inside of a prison where she was persecuted mercilessly and why? Because she had the guts to stand up to the racist, white entitled republicans who would relentlessly attack her. She made incredible changes to the corrupt justice system such as her advocation for the identities of children to not be revealed and for juveniles to not be shackled in court. When she was humiliatingly dragged from the court room like an animal, it wasn’t because of her reluctance to go, it was because of her medical state and also from a blow that she suffered, she isn’t a coward, the sherif made her look weak. She is a hero who once again (and there has been an evident pattern of instances alike) was taken down for being brave, for trying to change America for the better one state at a time. She has emerged early from prison not because she bribed anyone or annoyed the sherif into letting her go, she did it by helping others. And now she is still battling her wrongful prosecution and won’t stop until she gets the vindication that she so obviously deserves. If you see her as anything less than a victim of fascism but also a role model, you are seriously delusional.

    • Daniel on January 22, 2020 at 11:56 am

      You would obviously buy some land in Antarctica with that mentality. She was altering court documents to get her way AND gave classified document to her brother so he could keep his job. Obviously not the way an “honorable” judge should be behaving REGARDLESS of skin color. Stop drinking the racist cool aid.

    • G Jordon on February 12, 2020 at 8:06 am

      Thank you! Thank! Thank you! Couldn’t have said it better! Look at all the things done initially, trying to get her WIN for first black juvenile judge overturned? I, too, recently learned of this….we, as black with a huge mix of American Indian ancestry will NEVER give up. One day soon, minorities will out number the OTHER ethnic groups, hoorays!!! Remember history: this nation initially belonged to : NATIVE AMERICAN INDIANS!!!!

    • Owen C. Hines on February 16, 2020 at 10:35 am

      You know. When your black and trail blazing, you have to know that there is a chance that you will be targeted for everything that you do; and so you must … MUST do everything by the book. Don’t worry about when they catch you with your hand in the cookie jar that they would have treated a white person differently. Don’t put your hand in that Jar. You can’t afford to. Yes she had a hard time getting what was rightfully hers, and she still didn’t get there in the end. But she broke the rules in a big way; and if you’ve read everything pertaining to this case you’ll know that. Forget if she’s a sister or not. She messed up big style. She won’t be cleared; she’s as guilty as sin and the system has proved that. Face facts. She’s flawed. She was STUPID with a capital ‘S’ and that’s the end of her judicial career. Believe me.

  2. Francis X. McPhillips on October 27, 2019 at 10:41 pm

    Uhm…….. She broke the law. Therefore she SHOULD have spent the ENTIRE 6 months in jail. I wouldn’t doubt that she was released early by the Sheriff because he didn’t want to have to deal with her Lunacy any longer!!! Perhaps she should go ask Trump for a job!!!

    • Lane Love on January 9, 2020 at 10:57 am

      She would not get a job from Trump, but of course you would. You base everything on race just like him

  3. Jean-Luc Barrington on November 14, 2019 at 5:22 pm

    “Three Indiana judges involved in a Downtown Indianapolis fight in May.”

    “Adams’ whole blood alcohol level was approximately 0.157 upon admission to the hospital, and Jacobs’ was approximately 0.13, according to the opinion. Bell’s blood alcohol level was not tested, “but she was intoxicated enough that she lacks any memory of the incident,” per the opinion.”

    “Adams, who was the only judge criminally charged in the case, pleaded guilty to one count of misdemeanor battery in September. He received a sentence of 365 days in jail, a credit for two days served. The remaining 363 days of the sentence were suspended, meaning Adams served no additional jail time.”

    “All three judges received suspensions, but will eventually return to their offices.”

    Please confine ignorance to it’s respective bubble. These two incidents reveal undeniable bias.

  4. Captain Obvious on November 28, 2019 at 2:33 pm

    Written by a biased reporter with a track record for defending corrupt, black politicans.

  5. E Perkins on December 4, 2019 at 6:01 pm

    I don’t get it. If she wasn’t guilty, how did her brother end up with the documents in his possession? Did he ever get interviewed and deny she gave them to him? I don’t get it.

  6. That’s crap. She broke the law plain and simple! on December 14, 2019 at 8:07 am

    She’s a crook. She got caught and holds herself above the law. She needs to go start a new life and stay out of law.

    • Ben Coleman on December 18, 2019 at 11:24 pm

      Most caucasian folk have never had to worry about being discriminated against , so they don’t have a need to even begin to understand the plight of injustice . And because this country was taken over by barbaric English illiterate drunks , it’s no surprise that injustice is inherent. Just as they took this land from the original Americans , their blood thirsty and injustice manor is in their DNA. They can’t help themselves. The constitution say that this is one nation under God. I’d like to know what god they are talking about? I pray for all the people who have authority over us because this is the will of THE HEAVENLY FATHER. I thank God for wisdom. Owe no man anything except to Love him. “Vengeance is mine say’s The Lord” “I shall repay” All you people in this country treating people with unjust better get it together. White, black , yellow, red. What ever you call yourselves: Repent for the kingdom of God at hand. There shall be great weeping and gnashing of teeth.

      • Daniel on January 22, 2020 at 12:04 pm

        Another “victim” carrying the victim cross. Do people like you ever get tired of blaming everyone for your problems? At what point do you take responsibility for you actions? There is no systemic racism like you claim in other words. If there was, Obama wouldn’t have been elected to the white house, twice! There would be no Oprah, no JayZ and no Clarence Thomas in the Supreme Court.
        Are there racist people out there? Yes! And they would always exist. But the existence of racist people doesn’t equate to a racist country, were you have all the same right and opportunities as everyone else. People that only think or racism, only see racism.

      • Owen C. Hines on February 16, 2020 at 10:45 am

        Wow .. another victim.

        What about Fat caucasians, you can bet they’ve faced discrimination.
        What about Lesbian caucasians, you can bet they’ve faced discrimination.
        What about Gay caucasians, you can bet they’ve faced discrimination.
        What about Trump supporting caucasians, you can bet they’ve faced discrimination.
        What about Homeless caucasians, you can bet they’ve faced discrimination.
        What about Poor Drug abusing caucasians, you can bet they’ve faced discrimination.
        What about caucasians living in predominantly black neighbourhoods, you can bet they’ve faced discrimination.

        and the list goes on ….
        You have no idea.
        You are just another black person; probably an underachiever living under the safe umbrella of victimhood,
        and blaming that on all your woe’s …. How unfortunate.

  7. Andrew Fleming on December 26, 2019 at 4:25 am

    She is black and a Democrat with progressive ideas, they are white, Republican, racist and regressive, soon as she won the election over a Republican her card was marked, no need to say more! More power to her.

    • Randy Litton on January 1, 2020 at 10:44 am

      Amen. Why is this so hard for people to understand?

    • Daniel on January 22, 2020 at 12:14 pm

      Republicans are racist and regressive? Do you not know that it was the democrats that started the KKK? It was the democrats that fought to KEEP racist laws in the south. The only reason democrats accuse republicans of racism is because they’re trying to erase their history of racism.
      And regressive policies is one of the things democrats are pushing for. You don’t think that fighting to take constitutional rights from you is regressive? Then you must be a proud democrat. You don’t think that decriminalizing petty theft (San Francisco) is regressive? You don’t think that allowing millions of foreigners to come here at will is regressive? Democrats only way to get sheep like you to vote for them is to offer free stuff (paid by the gov) or appeal to some moral ground, regardless of how damaging that moral ground would be to the economy. Like AOC said, “some people are more concerned on being factually correct, than being morally correct.” Yeah, that is what democrats are pushing for, morally correct policies. Forget the economy, right?

      • She should have served a whole six months on February 15, 2020 at 3:28 pm

        Poetic Justice at its best. She should have served the entire 6 months.

    • Owen C. Hines on February 16, 2020 at 10:48 am

      So why was it sooooo hard for her to simply keep her nose clean and not do anything wrong ?.

      She has let you down. She has let all of us down.
      Face that fact and move on.

Leave a Comment